Why data, AI, and a little common sense need to work together.
Years ago, I almost helped put a donut on a national restaurant chain's permanent menu because of the alphabet.
Not customer demand. Not a brilliant marketing campaign.
The alphabet.
Let me explain.
While working for a national restaurant brand, my team was evaluating a promotional product: the apple donut.
According to the data, we had a runaway success. Sales were blowing past forecasts, and every report suggested we'd discovered a winner. We were on the verge of recommending that the apple donut become a permanent menu item.
But something made us dig a little deeper.
Turns out, the apple donut's biggest competitive advantage wasn't its taste, price, or marketing.
It was the letter A.
The apple donut button appeared first alphabetically on the cash register screen, and cashiers were pressing it more often than they should have when ringing up purchases.
Our superstar product wasn't necessarily a superstar at all. It just had prime real estate on the register.
Imagine the investment we could have made in production, marketing, and supply chain decisions based on those impressive numbers.
The data was real. The conclusion was wrong.
And I've never forgotten that lesson.
Now Add AI to the Equation.
For most of my career, I've lived by the saying, "The numbers don't lie."
I still believe in the power of data. But today, with AI, predictive analytics, and sophisticated dashboards, I'm increasingly convinced that numbers don't always tell us what we think they do.
We can analyze more information, faster than ever before. We can uncover patterns, generate forecasts, and produce compelling presentations in seconds.
We can also reach the wrong conclusion at record speed.
And let's be honest, a beautiful dashboard can make almost anything look convincing.
The challenge isn't always that someone is deliberately manipulating data. Sometimes we're simply choosing the metrics that support the story we already want to tell.
Marketing sees engagement. Sales sees conversions. Finance sees margins. Leadership sees growth.
Everyone has numbers. Everyone has a narrative.
But who's looking at the whole picture?
Data Informs. Experience Interprets. Strategy Directs.
This is where I believe experience, strategic thinking, and collaboration matter more than ever.
Data tells us what's happening.
Experience helps us understand why.
Strategy determines what we do next.
And collaboration brings the perspectives needed to challenge assumptions and uncover what we might otherwise miss.
I've spent much of my career helping organizations connect the dots between data, business objectives, customer behavior, and market realities.
And one thing I've learned is that the most valuable insights rarely come from a single metric. They come from understanding the story behind the numbers.
Not a story designed to justify a decision already made.
A story that reveals what's really happening, why it matters, and where to go next.
Sometimes that means questioning a forecast. Sometimes it means looking beyond short-term performance. And sometimes it means asking why a donut is selling so well.
The Numbers Don't Lead. We Do.
AI and advanced analytics are extraordinary tools. But they don't replace experience, curiosity, judgment, or the ability to bring people together around a sound strategy.
The goal isn't to have the most data or the prettiest dashboard.
It's to turn information into insight. And insight into meaningful action.
So perhaps it's time to update that saying I've carried throughout my career.
The numbers don't lie. But they don't always tell the whole story.
And they certainly don't lead.
That's still our job.
P.S. I still like apple donuts. I just wouldn't make a multimillion-dollar business decision based on their position in the alphabet.
Need help turning your organization's data into a compelling story?
At J MacRae Consulting Group, we help organizations make sense of their data, uncover meaningful insights, and connect the dots between performance, strategy, and business goals. We turn complex information into clear, compelling narratives that inform decisions, align stakeholders, and drive meaningful results.
Let's tell the story behind your numbers.

